Emotiva Reference MMC-1 AV Processor Review

Emotiva MMC-1 Introduction

Lately the Emotiva brand has been the talk of the town, at least on the internet that is. Perhaps it’s because of their very aggressive pricing or maybe their unconventional 40% off tradeup program on new processors for existing owners. Nah, I think it’s because their products look cool, sound great and are easy to operate. Whatever the reasoning, I am certainly finding a lot of great stuff to write about the brand.

In my opinion, however, Emotiva shines more with their amplifier offerings than their A/V processors. When Emotiva first introduced the DMC-1 a couple of years ago, it carried a hefty price tag of $3,500 and was pretty much outgunned (feature wise) by most of the big brand name receivers costing only ½ that price. This product was geared more towards the audiophile that desired simplicity and great sound over the latest video processing features or DSP mode to simulate the sound of your speakers submerged in a partially flushed toilet bowl. It had some operational quirks (such as component video upconversion issues, audio drop outs on DTS, or not properly engaging PLIIx modes, etc), but Emotiva was highly proactive in resolving them. For more details on this product, I suggest reading Clint’s review of the DMC-1.

In an effort to increase value to the consumer, Emotiva basically took the DMC-1 platform and updated it, eliminated a few features and brought the price tag down to $1,199 (nearly 67% cost reduction since the inception of the DMC-1). Enter the MMC-1, the newer and better A/V processor from Emotiva at a substantially reduced cost.

In order to understand the how the MMC-1 stacks up to the DMC-1, I have tabulated the differences for your convenience.

	MMC-1	DMC-1
HDMI Functionality	2x1 internal switcher w/ 1080p support	No HDMI, must use supplied external box
Balanced Outputs	Only sub out	8 CH
Remote Control	Custom Non Learning	Universal Learning MX-500
Weight	25 lbs	27lbs
Dimensions (HxWxD)	6” x 17.00 ” x 16 7/16"	6” x 17.00” x 16 7/16"

MMC-1 (left); DMC-1 (right)

Aside from these slight feature differences, there are cosmetic differences between the two products with the MMC-1 sporting Emotiva’s latest look which I am told by them will be their going forward appearance of their up and coming products. Personally I like this look at it reminds me of a Krell type product and isn’t as flashy or gimmicky looking as the DMC-1. The MMC-1 comes in a 3RU chassis with a milled aluminum faceplate and silver colored accent panel and has indirect cobalt blue illumination. My sample had rather sharp accent panels which Emotiva has told me they have filed down to make smoother since I noted it on this unit and my IPS-1 7CH test amplifier.

Editorial Note on Emotiva Build Quality
The MMC-1 utilizes an FR4 glass epoxy four layer mother board and in critical high speed areas such as the main DSP and video transcoder, up to eight layer PCB’s are used for signal integrity, ground plane, and impedance control purposes. The MMC-1 uses premium quality discrete A/D and D/A converters IC’s and a high performance, along with a high voltage 8 channel digitally controlled volume control IC. According to Emotiva, this is necessary for maximum headroom and enhanced sound quality, instead of a less costly multi-channel CODEC. Also employed is a low noise toroid power transformer and a fully regulated linear power supplies for the lowest possible electrical noise and radiated EMI. In contrast, many competitor processors use switch mode power supplies to save cost, but they usually do not offer the same noise performance.

Emotiva MMC-1 AV Processor Set-Up

Normally I am not one that shows pictures of product packaging in my reviews (in fact, I’ve been known to make fun of this when my reviewers include them), but I must say, I was quite taken by the very thorough packing job Emotiva did on these products. Not only were the MMC-1 and IPS-1 double boxed, but the inner box had thick stryofoam molded inserts to ensure the products were safe and snug – a great preventative countermeasure against the tyranny of the disgruntled shipping guy who is working overtime delivering your heavy package late in the day.

The user manual on the other hand is printed black and white single sided on a whopping 82 pages - can you guess how many trees it took to print this?) It’s held together with a big paper clip and reminds me of one of my weekly lab reports I had to turn in for my Fields and Waves Masters level class in engineering school. Despite its antiquated appearance, the user manual is actually well written and easy to follow for the most part. It even gives useful guidance, such as speaker placement suggestions and a couple of pages for you to write down your settings for future reference. To Emotiva’s credit, I later discovered they sent me an early production piece of the MMC-1 before their final manuals were printed. They informed me that manuals currently shipping with production units come in a plastic spined binder with heavy stock and double sided printed.

The system firmware can be updated as needed via the RS232 port on the backpanel. The latest firmware revision is located at: http://emotiva.com/support.shtm and I highly recommend periodically checking the site to ensure you have the latest revision. It’s good to see a company stand behind its product and continually improve upon its operation when issues arise.

I checked the firmware rev on my test unit and it displayed 2.02, which was not the current version according to the Emotiva website. Thus I broke out my DB9 cable and keyspan USB to RS232 cable and connected my laptop up to the MMC-1. By opening the executable file on Emotiva’s website, I was prompted to select a COM port that the MMC-1 was connected to. I selected “auto” and it found the processor on COM 4. I was then prompted with the screen capture shown here and the downloading process began. I noted the entire process took about 20 minutes so I strongly suggest using AC power if you are using a laptop and/or to disable any screensaver or powersaver options on your laptop to ensure no interruptions during the file transfer process.

Editorial Note to Emotiva
It would be most useful if you provide a laundry list of changes and fixes for each firmware version so the consumer can decide whether or not to upgrade their unit.

MMC-1 back panel view

Just like the DMC-1, the MMC-1 has a nice rear end. All of the RCA connectors are gold plated and the layout is clean, well organized and highly intuitive. Note the HDMI switching, a feature absent in the DMC-1. The MMC-1 still manages to support the high current (500mA) triggers, a feature rarely found on all but top end receivers and A/V processors.

I placed the MMC-1 and IPS-1 matching 7CH amplifier on my new Crystal rack from Audiav and sat in awe at how impressive they looked once installed in this masterful rack. I had comments from many industry folks that walked in my room and saw the Emotiva system powered on in my rack. They almost always asked about the cost and were dumbfounded when showed them the MSRP. “Surely they cant sound that good at that price,” they’d say. I'd reply, “Sit down for a listen… and don’t call me Shirley.”

I connected the system up to my Denon DVD-5910CI and utilized a host of speakers under review as well as my own reference speaker system (RBH Sound T-30LSE and speaker package, Velodyne DD-15 subwoofer). All cables were furnished by Impact Acoustics (Sonicwave toslink) and Bluejeans Cable (10AWG speaker cable and analog interconnects).

I tested the MMC-1 in several scenarios including 7-channels for home theater, two-channels in various listening systems currently under review, and critical two-channel evaluations with my main speakers bi-amped.

Remote Control

Emotiva MMC-1 AV Processor Listening Tests & Conclusion

CD: Dianne Reeves Never Too Far

You may have noticed this CD pop up in several of my most recent reviews. There is good reason for my repetitiveness here. Many of the tracks in this CD are an awesome test for a system's bass response and accuracy. The bass track in Track #2 “Never Too Far” will sound muddy on an improperly set up or mediocre system. I must have listened to this track 100 times when tuning my reference system's subwoofers - all four of which run in mono, cross over at 80Hz and are equalized through Audyssey MultEQ Pro. Turning off my two Velodyne DD-15 subs to do a strict two-channel evaluation, I listened to the track again with only the subs in my T30-LSE system handling the bass which were powered by the Earthquake XJ-600R digital amplifiers. As I commented in my IPS-1 review, I felt the IPS-1 was driving the bass portion of my speakers better than the more powerful Earthquake digital amplifier. The MMC-1 sounded very transparent to me as well. I did notice the noise floor greatly drop when engaged in “source direct” mode via analog connections to my DVD-5910CI. Two channel purists will definitely want to engage this mode when listening to 2CH analog sources.

SACD: Patricia Barber – Modern Cool

What good is critical music evaluation without testing out some high resolution source material such as one of my trusty Patricia Barber SACDs? Modern Cool is a superb sounding SACD that in my opinion every jazz lover should add to their collection. Track #7 “Company” is a reference track I use to separate REAL speakers from wimpy ones. The same can be said with upstream electronics, particularly amplification. When listening to this track, I closed my eyes to attempt to place where all of the instruments were coming from. The trumpets were dead center (thanks to the magnificent imaging capabilities of my reference speakers). They came at you crystal clear with a bit more of a bite to them then I recalled using the amplifiers in my Denon AVR-5805. The snare drums had plenty of snap to them and seemed to be emanating around and behind the speakers. Cymbal crashes were effortless and well delineated. Listening to the drum solo and twanging of the bass with my eyes closed gave me that “better than being there” experience placing me right in front of the drum kit in a cozy jazz cellar. All I was missing was a brandy Sniffer and a fine Cuban (cigar that is). The Emotiva combo had no problems being pushed hard on this song and the dual 10”s in my RBH T-30LSE’s loved the workout. I would say the Emotiva Theater Series combo has a larger than life sound quality not typically found at this price point. In 2CH “source direct” mode, you really get champagne taste at beer prices.

DVD-Audio: The Beatles Love

The Beatles Love DVD-A has become a benchmark multi channel recording that you will find referenced in many of my reviews. I would have never imagined the 40+ year old Beatles recordings could sound so good. “Because” originally on Abbey Road, was revitalized on this recording. The true dynamics of Lennon, McCartney and Harrison were revealed, reminding me there will never be another band like the Beatles. “Within You Without You/Tomorrow Never Knows” had a very psychedelic and floaty feel to it. I wasn’t expecting near 20Hz bass extension in this recording, but it was there for the T-30LSE system to playback without any contentions. I felt the floor joists rumble on this track just as I did with my reference rig powering my speaker system.

Unfortunately the MMC-1’s HDMI inputs don’t support audio, so I had to use the old fashion 6CH analog connection route. I didn’t overlay PLIIx Music Mode in this scenario because I felt the added A/D and D/A conversion stage slightly corrupted the fidelity by raising the noise floor. In the next generation processor from Emotiva, this won’t be an issue so until you can take advantage of their 40% trade up program, you’re gonna have to live with multi channel DVD-A and SACD discs in 5.1. Isn’t the convenience of our modern lives so sickening that an issue like this even crosses our radar?

Measurement & Analysis

Frequency Response

 

MMC-1 Frequency Response

In “source direct” mode, the Emotiva preamp is rule flat beyond 100kHz with a 3dB point in excess of my test gear which is limited to 200kHz. In normal stereo mode, the frequency response is limited to the ½ the sampling rate of the ADC as expected which in this case was 22kHz.

FFT Distortion Analysis

FFT Distortion Analysis at Full Power

At 3.5Vrms into a 600ohm load, the MMC-1 exhibited excellent distortion characteristics (10.865+77.616)dBv = 88.5dBV or 100*alog^-1(-88.5/20) = .0038% The slight rise in noise above 10kHz was perplexing, especially since the unit was engaged in “source direct”, but so low in the mud (-100dBV), that it really wasn’t worth further investigation.

Preamplifier Test Notes

The MMC-1, like the DMC-1 has an unusual amount of drive capability with a measured Max Vout of 6.5Vrms at less than 0.01% THD + N. The gain of the preamp is 7.28 or 17.2dB. This preamp has more than enough drive to hit maximum levels of any consumer audio amplifier I know of.

Signal to Noise ratio was less than stellar on this processor however. In “source direct” mode, I measured around 80dB (a-wt) with 200mV in and 1Vrms out which is quite good. With the ADC engaged, the SNR dropped nearly 30dB with the subwoofer on and nearly 40dB with the subwoofer off. The SNR corruption was mostly due to out of band noise so my measurements are far worse than what is actually audible. I found this unusual behavior to be only audibly noticeable if I was sitting within a few feet of my speakers with the volume gain cranked up to LOUD levels (>100dB at the listening position). Again this is not an issue if you use “source direct” for analog sources or if you stick your ears close to your speakers with the volume levels cranked.

Conclusions

My extensive listening and operational tests of the MMC-1 were virtually identical to that of the DMC-1 we previously tested. They are solid product offerings which are easy to operate, contain most of the features sought out in today’s more sophisticated home theaters, and in the new mantra of Emotiva – wont break the bank to own them. For those looking for a state of the art processor – look elsewhere or wait for the new batch of Emotiva processors do out early next year. For those seeking solid performance, with a high WAF, this is a good choice. Paired with the IPS-1 7CH power amp and Emotiva’s super trade up program on their processors, the Reference Theater Series separates combo becomes a great choice in the proverbial sea of consumer electronics options.

Emotiva Audio Corporation
106 Mission Court

Suite 101

Franklin, TN 37067

615-771-1224

877-EMO-TECH
Fax: 615-771-1128

MMC-1 Review
MSRP: $1,199

The Score Card

The scoring below is based on each piece of equipment doing the duty it is designed for. The numbers are weighed heavily with respect to the individual cost of each unit, thus giving a rating roughly equal to:

Performance × Price Factor/Value = Rating

Audioholics.com note: The ratings indicated below are based on subjective listening and objective testing of the product in question. The rating scale is based on performance/value ratio. If you notice better performing products in future reviews that have lower numbers in certain areas, be aware that the value factor is most likely the culprit. Other Audioholics reviewers may rate products solely based on performance, and each reviewer has his/her own system for ratings.

Audioholics Rating Scale

• — Excellent
• — Very Good
• — Good
• — Fair
• — Poor

Metric	Rating
Frequency Response Linearity
SNR
Multi-channel Audio Performance
Two-channel Audio Performance
Video Processing
Bass Management
Build Quality
Fit and Finish
Ergonomics & Usability
Remote Control
Performance
Value